This comes up again and again in my client sessions. A leader tells me, with total conviction, that they don’t know what to do. Not “I’m weighing two options,” but “I genuinely don’t know.”
One time that comes to mind is a woman who had two amazing job offers on the table. One came with some additional risks. The other was the safe option. She was very analytical, and she had been weighing pros and cons, good and bad, around and around.
So we tried a few different ways to quiet all that noise. Then I asked her: if you had to choose right now, no thinking allowed, which would it be?
She wanted the riskier one. She was simply scared that it wouldn’t work out.
That opened up a different question. Given that nothing is ever guaranteed, and either option might not work out, did she want to choose the one she actually wanted?
She did.
It’s worth naming clearly, because at the senior level it’s so easy to misdiagnose. When a leader says "I don't know what to do," it's rarely actually true. What's usually happening is that their judgment is there, intact, available — but it's being drowned out by a louder layer of anxious thinking: what if I'm wrong, what if this doesn’t work out, what will people think, what if I regret it. That layer is loud enough to convince you the judgment underneath it doesn't exist.
It does. It was there the whole time. It's just hard to hear over the noise.
This is different from confidence, which is a feeling that comes and goes. This is closer to instinct — the same capacity that got you promoted into this role in the first place, still running, still generating answers, just competing for airtime with everything your mind is anxiously generating alongside it.
The skill isn't building more judgment. You already have plenty. The skill is recognizing the moment when anxious noise is louder than your own thinking, and not mistaking that noise for the absence of an answer.
Next time you catch yourself saying "I don't know what to do," try asking the same question I asked her: if you had to decide right now, no thinking allowed, what would you do? You might be surprised how often the answer is already there, waiting for the noise to quiet down enough to hear it.
A question to sit with: Where in your leadership are you currently waiting for more certainty, when what you actually need is less noise?